E25. Should You Take Back a Former Client?

E25. Should You Take Back a Former Client?


    Get Creative Context delivered to your inbox each week

    0:00–1:15 – Introduction & Setup

    • The episode opens with a lighthearted tone and a metaphorical “walked off into the mist” visual.

    • Douglas and Eric introduce the topic: working with former clients again after a breakup—good or bad.


    1:16–4:45 – Personal Example: Client Returns After Break

    • Eric shares a real-life scenario: a former SEO client’s contract was dissolved, and they’ve now shown signs of interest in re-engaging.

    • He notes their site traffic dropped, which may be why they’re reconsidering.

    • The dilemma: do they want to return for genuine partnership or just to fix declining SEO?


    4:46–7:30 – Classifying Past Clients & Emotional Factors

    • Douglas reflects on clients in “tiers”:

      • Ones he’d ignore if they returned

      • Ones where he’d consider it

      • Ones he’d happily take back

    • He compares it to personal relationships—some breakups are final, others might work again if day-to-day interactions were good.


    7:31–10:00 – Caution, Patterns, and Guardrails

    • They explore how some clients “let you down easy” with false promises to return.

    • They caution against repeating cycles and recommend setting clear terms and contracts if re-engaging.

    • They use metaphors like “the same dance” or “bike with no momentum” to describe these risky returns.


    10:01–12:30 – Negotiation & Detachment

    • There’s value in revisiting clients when it comes from a place of strength—not desperation.

    • If revenue is stable without them, you’re in a better place to negotiate stronger terms and create clear boundaries.

    • Detachment from outcome is key: if they walk, you’re still fine.


    12:31–14:40 – Relationship Analogies

    • They revisit the personal relationship metaphor:

      • Initial excitement may fade.

      • If neither party has done personal/professional work to grow, old problems will return.

    • However, businesses can change more than individuals—new hires, different culture, etc.


    14:41–17:30 – Practical Considerations

    • Bringing a past client back could be easier with an intermediary buffer (e.g., working through a PR firm instead of directly with a problematic stakeholder).

    • Having that distance could neutralize personality conflicts.


    17:31–20:00 – Defining Guiding Principles

    • Eric realizes they may need clearer internal criteria:

      • What types of clients align with their values?

      • What makes an account a good fit?

    • Recommends using past experiences to create a values-based decision framework.


    20:01–22:30 – Upcoming Travel & Sidebar Chat

    • Eric talks about an upcoming trip to Omaha for a contractor summit and new gear setup.

    • Casual conversation about travel logistics and College World Series.


    22:31–24:30 – F1 Chat & Episode Wrap

    • Brief Formula 1 update: Mercedes, Verstappen, Lando Norris.

    • Final sign-off with podcast info and business plugs.

    You can also watch this podcast episode here


      Get Creative Context delivered to your inbox each week

      Other Episodes You May Like

      Ready to scale your business?

      Taking action is the bridge between dreams and reality—it's the first step that turns ideas into achievements.

      Get in Touch